Did Moses write a second book of Law and that was the one taken away?


Greetings my brother,

I'm very happy about the web site. I have studied a lot from it. I count many subjects that helped me to teach better through your web site. Thank you.

Regarding the Ten Commandments: There is a claim that the book that stood against them was the one next to the ark of the covenant which Moses wrote for them, Deuteronomy 31:23-26. They claim that was the book which was nailed on the cross Colossians 2:14. I don't know if I'm misusing the Scriptures if I do an exposition from II Corinthians 3:1-18 to prove that Ten Commandments are no more in the New Testament. If it's not scripture misuse, please help me by explaning more on the subject.

Thank you.


The use of II Corinthians 3:1-18 is appropriate. See: Paul's Service: Delivering a Glorious Message.

The idea that there was a second book has no basis in Scripture. Ask them where you can find this second book in the Bible and which passages are from the second book and with from the first book. My guess is that you'll find them intermingled. For example the laws on the Sabbath are not just in the Ten Commandments, they are also scattered in the other books. The same goes for laws in stealing, murder, etc. If there is not a clear delineation between these supposed two books, then the arbiter is  not God but man who desires to say which laws he will keep and which he will discard.